Grinder Throwdown: Virtuoso vs. Smartgrinder vs. Rocky
This entry was posted on August 22, 2012.
Looking for an entry-level espresso-grade grinder and not sure where to start? Well, we like a grudge match around here, so you may have seen the previous stand-offs between the Breville Smart Grinder vs the Rancilio Rocky and the Baratza Virtuoso vs Breville Smart Grinder. Those may have left you wondering: How do all three stack up against each other? Being the mind readers that we are at SCG, Kat and I used a Breville BES900XL and Velton’s Bonsai Blend to put these grinders through the paces.
Let’s compare them side-by-side:
|Baratza Virtuoso||Breville Smart Grinder||Rancilio Rocky|
|Burr Type||Conical steel||Conical steel||Flat steel|
|Case Material||Plastic||Brushed stainless steel||Stainless steel|
|Height||13 inches||14 inches||14 inches|
|Hopper Capacity||8 oz.||1 lb and hopper is removable!||8 oz.|
|Weight||16 lbs||5.6 lbs||18 lbs|
|Programmability||None||LCD screen lets you set grind (coarse to fine) volume (in cups and shots depending on fineness of grind) and dosage (weak to strong)||None|
|Timer or on/off switch||Timer and manual||Timer and manual setting||Manual only|
|Time to grind double shot||12 sec||22 sec||20-30 sec|
|Dosing||Only with timer, not by weight/volume||Automatically adjusts with grind; from coarser (dose in cups) to fine (dose in shots)||Doser avail for +$10, otherwise chute only|
|Grind consistency (1-5 scale, 5=most consistent)||40 individual step settingsFinest setting: 3
Coarsest setting: 1
|25 settingsFinest setting: 4
Coarsest setting: 2
|55 settingsFinest setting: 5, like talc
Coarsest setting: 3
|Shot performance (scale of 1-5, 5=strongest)||3: Overall, a solid shot, with the depth you’d expect from a fresh grind and proper dial-in.||4: A solid shot with great flavor and slightly more complex notes using the 2nd finest setting.||5: Shot has a great mouth feel, and you can taste more complexity and richness to the shot.|
|Notes||No frills, no fuss, easy to use, it’s a strong performer for espresso and other coffee applications. No electric panel makes trouble shooting a breeze as your grinder ages.||The lightest of the pack, this grinder is extremely versatile and a great value. It’s all about the features and accessories: portafilter holders, ground coffee canister, removable hopper to switch out beans.||Commercial quality for home use and it shows. Largest footprint of all grinders, a big commitment to your counter top, but with definite benefits in shot quality.|
The Rocky is a literal heavyweight coming in at 18 pounds and a hundred dollar heftier price tag, but there’s no doubt that the commercial quality burrs make a difference when it comes to tasting the complexity of your shot. I love the Virtuoso’s ease of use and inherent versatility, so it’s often my go-to for testing espresso, pour overs and french press. But like an ostrich, I am drawn to shiny objects and I wish it had more stainless in the casing. The Smart Grinder fulfills this need, and weighing in under six pounds means it doesn’t need to be a permanent fixture on your countertop – but it could be because it's great for households with multiple coffee drinkers with different bean preferences. What would you choose?